Why Modest or Timid
Both Pokémon mostly use special attacks in these games and have good Speed. Modest boosts Special Attack, while Timid boosts Speed. Both lower Attack, which neither Pokémon needs much.
- Modest is often preferred, since both Pokémon usually outspeed most in-game opponents anyway
- Timid is a fine choice if you want to be sure of moving first
- Lonely is not ideal here because the physical-special split had not happened yet in these games, so Fire and Electric moves are special
Pikachu or Raichu
Evolving Pikachu into Raichu lets you get more out of the nature and its stats.
In-game battles are mostly about hitting fast and hard, so do not worry too much if you already have a different nature.