Why raw stats do not decide it
- Staraptor is Normal and Flying, while Garchomp is Dragon and Ground, so they cover different things
- Staraptor is immune to Ground-type moves, while Garchomp is weak to Ice
- A team of six needs different types to cover each other's weaknesses
When comparing stats makes sense
A direct comparison is more useful between two Pokémon that fill the same role. For example, two Flying types you can get in Pokémon Platinum, such as Noctowl and Staraptor, compete for the same slot.
So look at your whole team and ask what it is missing, rather than only which Pokémon has the bigger numbers.
Team choice also depends on your own preferences and the battles you expect to face.