Base stats (Pidgeot / Staraptor)
- HP: 83 / 85
- Attack: 80 / 120
- Defense: 75 / 70
- Sp. Atk: 70 / 50
- Sp. Def: 70 / 60
- Speed: 101 / 100
Staraptor
Its 120 Attack pairs with Brave Bird, Double-Edge and Close Combat. Its ability Reckless boosts Brave Bird and Double-Edge, while Intimidate softens physical hits, which helps since its defenses are modest.
Pidgeot
Pidgeot has somewhat better defenses, but much lower Attack, and its Speed is about the same. It has a narrower physical movepool, so Steel types and sturdy Rock types can wall it. Staraptor can hit those with Close Combat.
This compares raw stats and typical movepools. Which one suits you also depends on your game, your team and the rules you play under.