How the gift works
- After defeating Benga, you can receive a Shiny Gible (Black 2) or a Shiny Dratini (White 2).
- It holds an Exp. Share and is given to you at Alder's house in Floccesy Town.
Why the key trick does not help
The key trade between Black 2 and White 2 lets you visit Black City or White Forest in the other game. But the Gible and Dratini gifts are version exclusives, so your game only hands out its own one.
To get the other Pokémon, you would need to trade with someone who has the other version.