Throh
- Bulky, with 120 HP and 85 Defense and Special Defense, and very good Attack.
- Ability Guts is solid, and you can find it early.
- Very slow, and has few great moves.
Scrafty
- Abilities Shed Skin and Moxie, with 90 base Attack.
- Defenses of 115 in both Defense and Special Defense, with 65 HP.
- Slow, but not as slow as Throh. It is found a gym or two after Throh and does not get really good until later.
Suggestion
Use Throh until you can get a Scraggy. Throh handles Lenora and general trainers well, while Scrafty does better in later gyms and the Elite Four.
Example sets
Throh: Guts with Vital Throw, Revenge and Focus Energy. Scrafty: Moxie or Shed Skin with Hi Jump Kick, Crunch and Dragon Claw.
These are casual in-game suggestions. A second answer also preferred Scrafty.